There are a lot of different competitive debating formats in the world. This can be
confusing as one encounters an alphabet soup of names. I hope that this very
short introduction can assist you in locating the format that is relevant to you.
University level competition:
WUDC/BP World Universities Debating Championship
NPDA/APDA American Parliamentary Debate, USA only
Policy Debate CEDA, NDT, USA only
Asians Format AUDC, NEAO, Asia only
Australs Australasian format, Australasian only
CUSID Canada only
NFA Lincoln Douglas, USA only
High school level competition:
WSDC World Schools Debating Championship
Karl Popper Debate IDEA
Policy Debate, USA only
Lincoln-Douglas Debate, USA only
Public Forum Debate, USA only
UNIVERSITY LEVEL COMPETITION:
WUDC/BP
Topics: New topic for each debate. '
Teams: Teams of 2, 4 teams in one debate, 2 proposition, 2 opposition,
judges rank teams 1-4.
Length: 60 minutes
Preparation: 15 minutes before the debate, no electronic access, only talk
to partner.
Interaction: Points of information from one side to the other.
Content: No quoted material, usually. Very few procedural or definitional
arguments.
Style: Faster than normal conversation, but accessible to all people.
Events: Worlds, Euros, Asians, Pan Africans, US, etc.
NPDA/APDA
Topics: New topic for each debate. Topic more binding for NPDA than
APDA.
Teams: Teams of 2, 2 teams, proposition and opposition.
Length: 45 minutes
Preparation: 20-30 minutes open preparation.
Interaction: Points of information.
Content: No quoted material.
Style: Some jargon, some procedural arguments,
Events: NPDA tournaments, NPTE, APDA tournaments.
POLICY DEBATE
Topics: One topic for entire academic year.
Teams: Teams of 2, 2 teams, affirmative and negative.
Length: 2-2.5 hours.
Preparation: Intense preparation during the entire year, extensive
research. Ten minutes preparation time to be used by each team during
the debate.
Interaction: Cross examination
Content: Lots of quoted material, lots of jargon, many procedural
arguments, but very open to innovation if you can defend it.
Style: Usually very rapid speaking.
Events: NDT, CEDA tournaments.
ASIAN
Topics: Three topics before each debate, teams determine which to
debate.
Teams: Teams of 3, 2 teams, government and opposition.
Length: About one hour.
Preparation: 30 minutes.
Interaction: Points of information.
Content: No quoted material, usually.
Style: A little faster than conversational, but understandable by all.
No comments:
Post a Comment